(Taken from the 1993 Sesquicentennial Booklet of the Church with the two most recent added)
The following is the list of pastors who have served this church. The list is divided into three groups: first, pastors who served when the church was part of the Sidney Mission; second, pastors who served the church when it was the head of the Knoxville Mission or Circuit, with the pastor serving several churches over a wide geographical area; finally, pastors who served the Church when it became a station, taking the entire time and service of a pastor:
Group 1
| Rev. John Zwahlen | 4 years | 1844-1848 |
| Rev. William Floerke | 3 years | 1848-1851 |
| Rev. Adolph Kaetter | 2 years | 1851-1853 |
| Rev. J. A. Schmermund | 2 years | 1853-1855 |
| Rev. F. Schimmelpfenning | 1 year | 1855-1856 |
| Rev. Charles Bauer | 2 years | 1856-1858 |
| Rev. J. C. Reiber | 2 years | 1858-1860 |
Group 2
| Rev. J. Gabler | 2 years | 1860-1862 |
| Rev. W. Ekermeyer | 2 years | 1862-1864 |
| Rev. J. Ficken | 3 years | 1864-1867 |
| Rev. J. C. Speckmann | 3 years | 1867-1870 |
| Rev. J. Leppert | 3 years | 1870-1873 |
| Rev. Phillip J. Grassle | 3 years | 1873-1876 |
| Rev. August F. Mueller | 3 years | 1876-1879 |
| Rev. J. K. Egly | 2 years | 1879-1881 |
| Rev. George Moering | 2 years | 1881-1883 |
Group 3
| Rev. John Hueneke | 2 years | 1883-1885 |
| Rev. J. A. Marquart | 5 years | 1885-1890 |
| Rev. W. E. Noeka | 5 years | 1890-1895 |
| Rev. Max Dieterle | 4 years | 1895-1899 |
| Rev. C. E. Buerkle | 4 years | 1899-1903 |
| Rev. Gustave Weiler | 1 year | 1903-1904 |
| Rev. John Bockstahler | 8 years | 1904-1912 |
| Rev. J. G. Schaal | 3 years | 1912-1915 |
| Rev. Paul L. Philipp | 8 years | 1915-1923 |
| Rev. E. I. Klotz | 4 years | 1923-1927 |
| Rev. D. Worthman | 4 years | 1927-1931 |
| Rev. J. C. Kluesner | 6 years | 1931-1937 |
| Rev. Dale M. Limbert | 3 years | 1937-1940 |
| Rev. T. A. Ballinger | 2 years | 1940-1942 |
| Rev. George H. Smith | 7 years | 1942-1949 |
| Rev. Gilbert P. Reichert | 2 years | 1949-1951 |
| Rev. Gilbert B. Heaton | 4 years | 1951-1955 |
| Rev. J. R. Wynd | 3 years | 1955-1958 |
| Rev. Robert Quick | 3 years | 1958-1961 |
| Rev. Walter Dickhaut | 2 years | 1961-1963 |
| Rev. John Gorton | 1 year | 1963-1964 |
| Rev. Wesley N. Mantle | 1 year | 1964-1965 |
| Rev. Herman Secoy | 2 years | 1965-1967 |
| Rev. Raymond Thompson | 4 years | 1967-1971 |
| Rev. Truman Hiatt | 3 years | 1971-1974 |
| Rev. C. L. Carnahan | 1 year | 1974-1975 |
| Rev. Jon W. Barker | 4 yearsv | 1975-1979 |
| Rev. James Waugh | 7 years | 1980-1987 |
| Rev. Ruth Card | 3 years | 1987-1990 |
| Rev. Alex Awad | 3 mos. | 1990 (interim) |
| Rev. Gale Gebhart | 2 1/3 years | 1990-1993 |
| Rev. Laurence E. Feaver | 5 mos. | 1993 (interim) |
| Rev. Mitchell Arnold | 12 years | 1993-2005 |
| Rev. Brian Vinson | 3 years | 2005-2008 |
| Rev. Dennis Gaertner | 2008- |
The following is a list of Ministers, Spouses, and Missionaries who came from this Church:
Rev. Theodore Lagemann, deceased in 1937.
Mrs. Elizabeth Lagemann Schanzlin, wife of Gottlieb Schanzlin, Missionary to India, deceased.
Rev. Edwin A. Rodeheffer.
Mrs. Luella Moellenkamp Philipp, wife of Rev. Otto Philipp.
Mrs Ethel Moellenkamp Ross, wife of Rev. Fred Ross.
Mrs. Adella Rodeheffer Whitcomb, wife of Elmer Whitcomb, M. D., Missionary doctor in India.
Mrs. Diane Shuster LaWarre, wife of Rev. Roger LaWarre.
Mrs. Barbara Kruse Starr, wife of Rev. Eric Starr.
Mrs. Peggy Katterheinrich Lammers, wife of Rev. Thomas Lammers.
Mrs. Jane Katterheinrich Hagen, wife of Rev. Kenneth Hagen.